
- Teacher: Dr Ayesha Abdullah
- Teacher: Hafsa Bibi
- Teacher: Sumayyah Saqib
- Teacher: Dr Neelofar Shaheen
- Teacher: Dr Uzma Siddique
- Teacher: Ehtisham Ul Haq

CONTACT SESSION -II
THEME 03
|
CERTIFICATE COURSE ON basic PRINCIPLES & PRACTICE OF HPE Theme 03: ASSESSMENT& EVALUATION |
|||
|
DAY 1 |
Saturday9-12-2017 |
|
|
|
Time |
Event |
Core Content |
Resource Person |
|
0800-0830 |
Introduction to the theme of the course |
Course outcomes Schedule Assessment |
Dr. Ayesha Abdullah |
|
0830-0910 |
Pre-test |
|
Dr. Urooj Saleem |
|
0910-1010 |
Principles of assessment |
Purpose of assessment and types How to choose the best approach to assessment · Validity · Reliability · Educational impact · Cost-effectiveness · Acceptability |
Dr Ayesha Abdullah |
|
1010-1100 |
Process of Assessment |
The algorithm of Assessment ü Standard setting ü Blue printing ü modes and methods of assessment for various domains of learning ü Feedback ü Assessment of assessment- Educational Evaluation & Research |
Dr Ayesha Abdullah
|
|
1100-1130 |
Break & Discussion |
|
Mr. Muhammad Asim |
|
1130-1330 |
The written examinations |
Levels of cognition and the tools for written assessments CRQs, MEQs, SAQs, Essay Questions MCQs, EMQs |
Dr Ayesha Abdullah
|
|
1330-1400 |
Sum-up & Debriefing |
|
Dr. Urooj Saleem |
|
CERTIFICATE COURSE ON basic PRINCIPLES & PRACTICE OF HPE Theme 03: ASSESSMENT& EVALUATION |
|||
|
DAY 2 |
Monday11-12-2017 |
|
|
|
Time |
Event |
Core Content |
Resource Person |
|
0830-0900 |
PP-1: Assessment of Learning outcomes for the competent and reflective physicians |
AMEE Guide 57 |
Presenter Dr. Ambreen Humayun Dr. Fahadullah Dr. Qurat-ul-AinEvaluator Ayesha Abdullah |
|
0900-0930 |
Introduction to Performance Assessment |
Assessment of Competence and performance |
Dr. Raheela Yasmin |
|
0930-1030 |
Practical Examinations |
OSCE, OSPE
|
Dr. Raheela Yasmin |
|
1030-1100 |
Break & Discussion |
|
|
|
1100-1140 |
Assessment of attitude |
Why How and when matrices |
Dr. Raheela Yasmin |
|
1140-1240 |
Work-based assessment |
Rationale Tools Reliability and validity |
Dr. Urooj Saleem |
|
1240-1400 |
Exercise WBA & Practical Exam OSCE/OSPE |
|
Dr. Urooj Saleem |
|
1400 |
Sum-up & Debriefing |
|
Dr. Urooj Saleem |
|
DAY 3 |
Tuesday12-12-2017 |
|
|
|
Time |
Event |
Core Content |
Resource Person |
|
0800-1000 |
MCQs Presentation-I |
Participant Presentations |
Dr Ayesha Sumera Abdullah |
|
1000-1030 |
Break & Discussion |
|
|
|
1030-1200 |
MCQs Construction |
Purpose Process Quality assurance |
Dr Ayesha Sumera Abdullah |
|
1200-1240 |
Workup on MCQs Based on feedback |
Individual work-up |
Dr Ayesha Sumera Abdullah & Dr Urooj Saleem |
|
1240-1400 |
MCQs Presentation-II |
Participant presentations |
Dr Ayesha Sumera Abdullah |
|
1400 |
Sum-up & Debriefing |
|
Dr. Urooj Saleem |
|
CERTIFICATE COURSE ON basic PRINCIPLES & PRACTICE OF HPE Theme 03: ASSESSMENT& EVALUATION |
|||
|
DAY 4 |
Wednesday13-12-2017 |
|
|
|
Time |
Event |
Core Content |
Resource Person |
|
0800-0930 |
Other tools for written assessments CRQ,EMQs & MEQs |
Purpose Process Quality assurance |
Dr Ayesha Sumera Abdullah |
|
0930-1030 |
Exercise EMQs, CRQ, MEQs |
Group work |
Dr Ayesha Sumera Abdullah |
|
1030-1100 |
Break & Discussion |
|
|
|
1100-1200 |
Group Work Presentations |
Participant Presentations |
Dr Ayesha Abdullah |
|
1200-1300 |
Teaching & Learning in Clinical Settings |
Principles Models Quality Assurance |
Dr Saima Ali |
|
1300-1330 |
PP-2: Blueprint to assess professionalism: Results of a systematic review |
Article from study material |
Presenter Dr. Saira Gul Dr. Fida Muhammad Dr. Samina Evaluator Dr Saima Ali Dr Ayesha Abdullah |
|
1330-1400 |
PP3- A model for communication skills assessment across the undergraduate curriculum |
Article from study material |
Dr. Hina Khan Dr. Shah Nawaz KhanDr. Muhammad Arif Dr Saima Ali Dr Ayesha Abdullah |
|
CERTIFICATE COURSE ON basic PRINCIPLES & PRACTICE OF HPE Theme 03: ASSESSMENT&EVALUATION |
|||
|
DAY 5 |
Thursday14-12-2017 |
|
|
|
Time |
Event |
Core Content |
Resource Person |
|
0800-0930 |
Essentials of Assessment |
Standard setting Blue printing Assessment of Reliability and Validity of assessment |
Dr. Usman Mehboob |
|
0930-1030 |
Evaluation of Exam Items |
How can the examination items be evaluated? What are components of item analysis for written and practical exams? How to interpret an item analysis report? |
Dr.Usman Mehboob |
|
1030-1110 |
Post-test |
|
Dr. Urooj Saleem |
|
1110-1130 |
Break & Discussion |
|
|
|
1130-1200 |
Evaluation of PBL,TBL,CBL |
Process Evaluation QA in assessment of these sessions |
Usman Mehboob |
|
1200-1240 |
PP 4:Formative assessment
PP 5:Formative assessment and self‐regulated learning: a model andseven principles of good feedback practice |
Chapter by Diana F. Wood from Understanding medical Education in the Study material Article of Studies in Higher Education from the study material |
Presenter Dr. Muhammad Irfan Dr. Waqar Muhammad
Presenter Dr. Raza Dr. Mehreen Imran
Evaluator Dr. Usman Mehboob |
|
1240-1330 |
Evaluation of Behavior |
Why do we need to evaluate behaviours? When and how? QA in evaluation of behaviours. |
Usman Mehboob |
|
1330-1400 |
Prayer Break |
|
|
|
1400-1430 |
Lunch |
|
|
DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH PROFESSIONS EDUCATION
& RESEARCH (DHPE&R)
CME/CDE ON RESEARCH METHODOLOGY, BIOSTATISTICS & research PROPOSAL WRITING
April
2017
Introduction
This course is meant to empower the novice researchers with the skills needed to accomplish their research goals. It is a practical- oriented short course with ample opportunity for hands-on practice of core research skills. The pre-reading for the course will assist the participants in building a sound foundation for their research competency.
CME/CDE Duration
This CME/CDE comprises three consecutive workshops on Research Methodology, Biostatistics with SPSS & Developing Research Proposal. The total duration of the set of workshops is 4 weeks, with 3 weeks pre-reading and one week face-to-face teaching and learning sessions if you attend all the three workshops.
Course Assessment
The assessment of the course (All the three workshops) for MPhil and PhD postgraduate students comprises the following indicators.
|
Assessment of pre-reading |
10% |
|
Group Work |
10 % |
|
Individual Assignments |
20 % |
|
End-of-course Written Assessment |
20% |
|
End- of- course Assignment |
40% |
For faculty members the certification of the course could be based on complete attendance of the individual workshops and the in-house assignments.
Maximum of 5 Bonus Marks for Asking Quality Questions
Course Certification
Participants who attend all the three workshops and submit their individual and final assignments on time would earn CME/CDE certificate from Riphah Academy of Research and Education (RARE), Riphah International University.
Pre-reading for the course (3 weeks)
Compulsory Reading
· WHO Regional Publications, EMR Series 30. A practical Guide for Health Researchers- Cairo 2004.WHO, Regional Office for EMR
· Lancet Series on Epidemiological Studies
Suggested Reading
· Petrie A, Sabin C. Medical Statistics at a Glance. Oxford Blackwell Science 2000
· SPSS- Advanced Statistics 17.0
Course Fee
All the Three workshops together …………………………. Rs.3000
Individual workshops ……………………………………………. Rs.1500
Registration
The registration forms are available at the Department of Health Professions Education & Research,
Last Date of Registration
For PGs-1st April 2017
For Faculty: On Desk
CME/CDE on Research Methodology, Biostatistics & Proposal Writing
Workshop 01: Research Methodology
|
DAY 01: 10th APRIL (Monday) |
|||
|
Activity |
Learning Outcomes By the end of this session the participants would be able to:- |
Resource Person |
Time |
|
1. Welcome & Start-up |
· · Pre- test |
Dr. Ayesha S Abdullah |
0800-0900 |
|
2. Introduction to the importance of research in our professional life |
· Recognize the importance of research as an essential obligation for professional practice and personal growth. · Identify essential steps of the research process and recognize the importance and implications of its cyclical nature. · Typology of research |
Dr. Ayesha S Abdullah |
0900-1000 |
|
3. Ethics in research - |
· Compare contemporary ethical paradigms that underpin the basic ethical principles of biomedical research. · Identify ethical issues and suggest ways to minimize ethical concerns, with reference to the governing ethical principles in each of the given case studies. |
Dr. Ayesha S Abdullah |
1000-1100 |
|
Break 1100-1130 |
|||
|
4. Literature Review |
Conduct an appropriate literature review for a given topic. |
Dr. Mohammad Irfan |
1130-1230 |
|
DAY 02: 11th APRIL (Tuesday ) |
|||
|
Activity |
Learning Outcomes By the end of this session the participants would be able to:- |
Resource Person |
Time |
|
5. Selection of topic for research |
Select an appropriate and feasible topic for their research utilizing frameworks introduced in the course. Refine a research topic into a research “title”. |
Dr. Ayesha S Abdullah |
0800-0900 |
|
6. The basis of research- Research Question & Objectives hypothesis |
· Write research objectives for the topic that they would have selected as a research project. · Frame research questions for their research project. · Write hypothesis for a given research case. · Differentiate between the use of research objective, question and hypothesis. |
Dr. Ayesha S Abdullah |
0900-1000 |
|
Break 1000-1030 |
|||
|
7. Generating research hypothesis |
· Write research hypothesis for a given research case. · |
Dr. Zahid Jadoon Dr Durdana Tariq |
1030-1130 |
|
8. How to manage Reference Research Material with Endnote, Zotero and cite references & Exercise |
· Perform basic functions with Endnote and Zotero Cite reference of reviewed studies in Vancouver and APA system of referencing |
Dr.Urooj Saleem |
1130-1230 |
|
9. Group work |
· Analyze selected research projects using priority matrix. · Write research questions and objectives for their selected projects. |
|
1230-1330 |
Workshop 01: Research Methodology
Workshop 01: Research Methodology
|
DAY 03 : 12th APRIL 2017 (Wednesday) |
|||
|
Activity |
Learning Outcomes By the end of this session the participants would be able to:- |
Resource Person |
Time |
|
10. How to select an appropriate study design? Introduction to study design & Discussion of cross sectional study designs |
· Recognize the importance of selecting the appropriate study design in the research process. · |
Dr. Zahid Jadoon Dr Asif Rehman |
0830-0930 |
|
11. Case Control |
· Evaluate a given case control and cohort study against the objectives and conclusions of the study. |
Dr. Zahid Jadoon Dr Asif Rehman |
0930-1030 |
|
Break 1030-1100 |
|||
|
12. Cohort Study Designs |
· Evaluate a given cohort study against the objectives and conclusions of the study. |
Dr. Zahid Jadoon Dr Asif Rehman |
1100-1200 |
|
13. Hands-on Session Exercise on Cross Sectional Studies |
· Evaluate given cross sectional, case –control and cohort studies against their objectives and conclusions. |
Dr. Ayesha S. Abdullah |
1200-1300 |
Workshop 01: Research Methodology
|
DAY 04 : 13th APRIL 2017 (Thursday) |
|||
|
Activity |
Learning Outcomes By the end of this session the participants would be able to:- |
Resource Person |
Time |
|
14. Review Case-control and cohort study designs |
Review |
Dr. Ayesha S. Abdullah |
0800-0900 |
|
15. Experimental Study Designs
|
Suggest appropriate experimental design for given experimental conditions. · |
Dr. Zahid Jadoon Dr Asif Rehman |
0900-1030 |
|
Break 1030-1100 |
|||
|
16. Designing Tools for data collection
|
Design appropriate, valid and reliable tools for the data collection of the chosen study in line with the objective and research question. |
Dr. Asif Rehman |
1100-1200 |
|
17. Exercise Evaluation of sample experimental studies |
· Evaluate a given experimental study against the research questions/ hypothesis and the conclusions drawn from the reported results. |
Dr. Asif Rehman |
|
|
DAY 05 :14th April 2017 (Friday ) |
|||
|
18. Sampling
|
· Identify appropriate sampling technique for a given set of objectives. · Compare various sampling strategies. · |
Dr. Zahid Jadoon Dr Durdana Tariq |
0830-1030 |
|
Break 1030-1050 |
|||
|
19. Group Exercise |
· Calculate sample size for a given case. |
Dr. Zahid Jadoon Dr Durdana Tariq |
1050-1130 |
|
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
20. Individual Exercise Sampling |
Identify appropriate sampling technique for the objectives of their own research projects. |
Dr. Zahid Jadoon |
1130-1230 |
Workshop 02: Biostatistics with SPSS
|
DAY 06 : 15th April 2017 (Saturday) |
|||
|
Activity |
Learning Outcomes By the end of this session the participants would be able to:- |
Resource Person |
Time |
|
1. Data Management & Introduction to SPSS |
Use data management techniques for a given data set. Create file, and perform basic functions in SPSS |
Dr. Durdana Khan |
0800-0900 |
|
2. Defining and operationalizing study variables
SPSS- Defining variables |
Define and operationalize variables
Define variables and create new variables with SPSS |
Dr. Durdana Khan |
0900-1000 |
|
Break 1000-1030 |
|||
|
3. Descriptive statistics with SPSS- Exercise based session |
Perform descriptive analysis of a given set of data in SPSS |
Dr. Durdana Khan |
1030-1230 |
|
4. |
|
|
|
|
DAY 07 : 17th April 2017 (Monday ) |
|||
|
Activity |
Learning Outcomes By the end of this session the participants would be able to:- |
Resource Person |
Time |
|
5. Inferential statistics with SPSS- Principles of significance test with Exercise on SPSS |
Perform inferential analysis of a given set of data in SPSS. Identify and interpret various tests of significance for a given set of research questions, objectives and data.
|
Dr. Zahid Jadoon Dr Durdana Tariq |
0830-1030 |
|
Break 1030-1050 |
|||
|
6. Correlation statistics |
Interpret linear correlation between variables |
Dr. Zahid Jadoon Dr Durdana Tariq |
1050-1130 |
|
7. Data presentation/ Exercise |
Identify appropriate method of data presentation for a given set of data and the purpose of the study. |
Dr. Asif Rehman |
1130-1230 |
|
8. Group Work |
Inferential analysis of a given set of data in SPSS. |
|
1230-1400 |
Workshop 03: Developing Research Proposals
|
DAY 08 : 18th April 2017 (Tuesday) |
|||
|
Activity |
Learning Outcomes By the end of this session the participants would be able to:- |
Resource Person |
Time |
|
1. How to write a good research proposal / Format for PGs |
Familiarize themselves with the characteristics of a good research proposal and the format used by PMC for PGs for the submission of their research proposals. |
Dr. Zahoorullah |
0800-0930 |
|
2. Quality Assurance in Research
|
Identify important quality assurance measures to enhance the validity and reliability of a given research study.
|
Dr. Ayesha S. Abdullah |
0930-1000 |
|
3. Budgeting |
· Develop a budget proposal for their research study. · |
Dr. Asif Rehman |
1000-1040 |
|
4. Budgeting Group Exercise |
1040-1120 |
||
|
Break 1120-1140 |
|||
|
5. Gantt Chart |
Gantt chart the activities of their research project |
Dr. Asif Rehman |
1140-1220 |
|
6. Post-test |
· |
Dr. Ayesha S Abdullah |
1220-1400 |
|
DAY 09 : 19th April 2017 (Wednesday) |
|||
|
Activity |
Learning Outcomes By the end of this session the participants would be able to:- |
Resource Person |
Time |
|
Presentation of Individual Research Proposals to the panel
|
Present their research proposal in a 10 minutes presentation according to the given format |
Panel 01: 0830-1100 Dr. Muhammad Aman Khan , Dr. Muhammad Irfan Dr. Farhat Malik, Dr. Ayesha S. Abdullah Dr. Urooj Saleem Panel 02:1100-1300 Dr. Zahoorullah Dr. Muhammad Irfan Dr. Durdana Khan Dr. Ayesha S. Abdullah Dr. Asif Rehman |
0830-01300 |
|
Course Feedback |
Feedback |
Dr. Urooj Salim |
1300-1330 |
Guidelines for End-of-Course Assignment
Final Individual Assignment: Complete research proposal presentation on the following format:
· Title (Slide 1)
· Introduction with rationale of the study (Slide 2)
· Objectives, research questions/ hypothesis (Slide 3,4)
· Methods (Slide 5,6)
o Study Design
o Sampling & sample size
o Method for data collection with tools for data collection (hyperlink)
o Method for Analysis
· Ethical Issues (Slide 7)
· Budget (Slide 8)
· Gantt Chart (Slide 9)
· References (7-10)-(Slide 10)
· Total number of slides=10
· Maximum Time -07 minutes with Q &A= 5 minutes
This
course is meant to empower the novice researchers with the skills needed to
accomplish their research goals. It is a practical- oriented short course with
ample opportunity for hands-on practice of core research skills. The pre-reading for the course will assist
the participants in building a sound foundation for their research competency.